Variable Cell

The Idea

Drone, large cell(5.4mm) and small cell(4.9mm) foundation.

Is it possible to trick bees into building a natural broodnest structure, consisting of a variety of cell sizes, on a single frame?

  • would they draw out a variable cell size foundation as easily and rapidly as they do natural comb?
  • would they detect and remove mite-infected brood?

If it’s possible, then all the advantages of a natural broodnest could be realized in standard frame and foundation based equipment with its strength, compatibility and flexibility.

Nice idea. But this test just didn’t work. The bees didn’t like this approach at all. This is one way not to do it.

The Details

Setup

Test frame.

I obtained some drone sized foundation, some large cell foundation and some small cell foundation. I cut a:

  • 1 1/2″ strip of the drone foundation
  • 1 1/2″ strip of the large cell foundation
  • and a 5 1/2″ strip of small cell foundation to fill out the balance of a deep frame

Drone foundation was inserted at the frame’s top. The large cell foundation was inserted next. It slightly overlapped the bottom edge of the drone foundation. The small cell foundation was inserted last. It slightly overlapped the bottom edge of the large cell foundation. The Y orientation was maintained between the different sized foundations. They were squeezed together where they overlapped.

This hybrid foundation was embedded in a standard frame with the largest cells at the top to mimic how the bees construct natural comb.

Four deep frames were prepared and inserted, in various locations, in my small cell hives at the end of June. These hives consisted of 3 deep boxes filled with bees. The yellow sweet clover flow was on. It was a great time to draw out some foundation.

One frame was inserted in the center of the broodnest, in the middle box. Another frame was inserted on the edge of the broodnest. Another was inserted above it and another below it. Each frame went in a different hive.

Results

I inspected them several weeks later. This test was a complete flop. The bees worked the drone comb. They wanted larger worker sized cells and drew it out freely. But they made a mess of the small cell size, with lots of odd shapes and transitional areas. Only a few square inches of good small cell comb was found. Everything else was reworked to a larger size. This was the worst case of small cell comb building I’ve seen. It was so bad that I culled it on the spot. Then realized I hadn’t photographed it. Sorry. 🙁

At least I know what doesn’t work. It appears location is everything regarding nest structure. The bees aren’t easily fooled. But maybe I’m not tricky enough!

Thoughts

Other Options

Worker brood cell sizes aren’t distinct but gradually taper from one size to another. In this test, the cell sizes abruptly changed. Maybe the best approach is to heat and stretch some small cell foundation so that a gradient in cell size is more natural. Or a foundation mold could be built using natural broodnest comb as the master.

Another Approach

Different sized comb could be obtained, in standard equipment, by running both large and small cell frames within a hive. Frames with small cell comb would occupy the interior. Frames with large cell comb could be used toward the exterior. When my supply of small cell combs was limited, I ran six small cell frames in the middle of a brood box and four large cell frames on the exterior without loosing mite tolerance. Observations from my top bar hive indicate that four small cell frames should work. Such a small amount of comb could be drawn in five frame nucs and inserted in larger hives.

-bW

Share on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

One response to “Variable Cell”

  1. -bW says:

    Bye Bye Foundation

    Since my top bar hive observations, I’ve abandoned developing a natural approach to foundation. At the time of this test, I was a commercial beekeeper and couldn’t think much beyond foundation. It’s all I knew.

    My beekeeping now focuses on cooperating with the honeybee rather than forcing them to work with either my equipment or management. Bees easily and effortlessly build natural comb. Why not let them do what they do best.

    So, finding an acceptable foundation is no longer an issue for me. With natural comb, the bees do comb their way. And there’s much less cost and effort for the beekeeper, both when installing and when recycling/rotating frames.

    Natural combs are more delicate and must be handled carefully. But, if you need the strength foundation provides, and desire the benefits of natural comb, here’s what not to do. 😉

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *